Time for a new headshot

Which one should I choose?

I decided to play with a lighting setup.
Up at a 45 degree angle i placed a soft box just above my head. Then in from of the camera i placed tow 'V' Flats ( Large white boards ) and faced them directly at me…I the fired two speed lights back into the 'V' flats to eliminate too much shadows under my eyes caused by the soft box up above..this helped soften the lower light on my faces….as the shoot prevailed I started to turn the 'V' flats slightly off center to create more shadow on the side of my cheeks and jaw line…..15 minutes of screwing around and viola!